Hatchery pipeline on Ute sacred ground halted for 30 days
by Mary Bernard
3 months ago | 567 views | 2 2 comments | 10 10 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Monday’s tribal court determination found in favor of the Ute Tribe over the matter of the highly contested Big Springs sacred site near the Ute Tribal Fish Hatchery in-construction.

Ute Tribal Court was convened to request an injunction in the construction of a pipeline from Big Springs to a newly developed fish hatchery below the springs.

Judge William Reynolds found for the Tribe, saying that following all “federal formal requirements, ten years and six different Ute tribal business committees the project to construct the Fish Hatchery was allowed to proceed.”

But, Reynolds stated that “a 30-day session of pipeline construction from the spring” was required to bring concerned parties together to re-evaluate the situation.

An Environmental Assessment for the Big Springs fish hatchery was completed and the record of decision was issued nearly a decade ago.

However, on Sept. 22 a protest by tribal members at the Big Springs Sacred Site resulted in the arrest of tribal religious leaders Jerry Tapoof and Kylie Thompson.

They were arrested along with the detainment of others after damage to the sacred site from construction efforts was made plain before the protesters.

According to tribal members who spoke in the Court, “the springs are a traditional religious site that must flow naturally without being tapped into a pipeline. And, here there were trees removed and offerings disturbed. It’s a sacrilege.”

Roughly 30 tribal protesters were detained and removed from springs location on Bureau of Land Management, but not arrested. Only traditional spiritualists Tapoof and Thompson were cited while the remainder were removed from the construction area as John and Jane Doe(s).

“I was arrested in defense of my tradition, a right guaranteed me and all Native Americans under the constitution,” said Tapoof, a Ute Tribal traditional spiritual leader, who said their arrest on public land was unwarranted.

Their arrests at a traditional religious site have gained national recognition as Tapoof stated he has received calls from as supporters across the country.

The criminal case of the arrested tribal leaders remains a separate matter; however, Tapoof says he remains more concerned about the welfare of the Big Springs sacred site than his.

mbernard@vernal.com
comments (2)
« Phillip Gottfredson wrote on Wednesday, Oct 14 at 10:52 PM »
First let me make it clear I am not a Ute or a Indian, but never the less I think the way this came about with no apparent regard to the Utes sacred and holy site is an outrage! If this sacred site was a Mormon church there would be plenty of concern from the public. But why is this any different? Is it because they are Indians? To arrest spiritual leaders for protecting the Utes holy site, and treat them as criminals is absolutely absurd! These are men who have dedicated their lives to helping others. They inspire our youth to overcome the temptations of life. They give guidance and council to people who are lost and confused, ill and broken. Big Springs is to these men and those they help it's their medicine, a sacred grove, a place of worship and inspiration. It's not a place for a fish hatchery, or to be used for such purposes. These men and people who stood in protest--took a stand for something good, pure, natural, things this world needs more of. Good people with good intentions, these are the people we need most in our broken society to inspire us, lead us, and help us when we are most vulnerable. It is a sacrilege to target these men and banish them from their sacred site. For too long the Ute have been the victims of discrimination. They have the same unalienable right to a decent life as do all human beings.

My hope and prayer is that the judge and Ute leaders will make the only right decision and let Big Springs alone, find water for the hatchery elsewhere. The Hatchery needs water, but the Ute need their most sacred traditions more.



« Jasanna Cuch wrote on Wednesday, Oct 14 at 03:08 PM »
Yes, this project was presented 10 years ago and what degree did they aware the Ute Nation? The project leads stated they had 106 enrolled members contacted via mail and 1 spiritual leader. Although Northern Ute attorney failed to state that our tribal enrollment consists of 3,000 Northern Ute members. Does that 106 and 1 spiritual leader justify notifying 2 Sundance chiefs or any spiritual & ceremonial people or the enrolled members at that? F&W also failed to notify the Ute Nation which indicated 17 public meetings throughout the Uintah and Ouray reservation and communities. They conducted 3 meetings.

Yes our Northern Ute Sundance chief and Sundancers were summonds to appear before the Tribal judge and careful witness our Northern Ute Tribal Attorney work his law skills against his own persons who employee him. The Ute Nation! I ask myself isn't this enthical to for our own tribal attorney file suet agains the Ute Nation? Within the 10 years yes it was an established project which failed approval under various business committee representatives. We don't deny 10 year project but we as a Ute people have every right to protect the sacred springs. It is our fundamental right as a Native American person to protect our culture and rights especially our sacred locations and excerising our rights withiin our tribal jurisdiction!

If we continue to allow dictators such as our leadership to continue dicating to us then we don't need to think for ourselves! We have a obligation as Native Americans because that is exactly what our ancestors would have wanted it to be!

Inconclusion this small group of ENROLLED members of the Ute Tribe are in this struggle to maintain our Ute traditional ways.

Signed

Jasanna Cuch

Northern Ute Tribe

queenbeejacee23@hotmail.com

435-724-1026